Nudge Wiki

Concept

Time Affluence

happiness time-use well-being

Cassie Holmes's research finds the relationship between discretionary (freely-chosen) time and happiness is an inverted U-shape, not a straight line: having too little free time predictably makes people less happy, but so does having too much — happiness peaked somewhere in the middle, with both under 2 hours and over 5 hours of daily discretionary time associated with lower reported happiness in an analysis of tens of thousands of Americans' detailed daily time-use diaries (see Discretionary Time Inverted-U Happiness Study).

Why too much free time backfires: unstructured time with nothing to show for it undermines a person's sense of purpose, producing dissatisfaction rather than relief — the same restlessness many people recognize from the last idle stretch of a long summer holiday. The dip disappears, however, for discretionary time spent on purposeful, worthwhile activities specifically — hobbies that build a skill, and especially socializing. Nobel laureate Daniel Kahneman's day-reconstruction study of roughly 900 working women found socializing with friends or family (or physical intimacy) were consistently rated the most enjoyable activities of an ordinary day, more so than passive leisure like watching TV (see Kahneman Day-Reconstruction Activity-Enjoyment Study).

Time over money. Across several studies, people who said they'd prefer more time over more money reported higher life satisfaction than people who preferred more money — a relationship that held regardless of how much of either resource a person actually had. Priming people to think about time (versus money) shifted how they subsequently spent their time toward more socially- and value-aligned activities, reduced cheating, and reduced total time spent working — except among young workers who found their work itself deeply fulfilling, for whom thinking about time increased how much they worked (see Time-vs-Money Preference and Priming Studies).

A related, later finding (Episode 131): treating remaining time as scarce rather than abundant — even just by writing about it that way — measurably raises how much people enjoy and make of that time, replicated in a study of college seniors approaching graduation (see College Seniors Time-Scarcity Happiness Study). Exercise and time outdoors also feed time affluence specifically via self-efficacy: making time for exercise, even when time feels scarce, increases the felt sense of having accomplished something with the time available (see Hedonic Adaptation).

Discussed in

  • Episode 129 — 129-can-too-much-free-time-make-you-unhappy
  • Episode 131 — 131-tips-for-living-a-happier-life-according-to-science (time-scarcity framing; exercise and self-efficacy)

Related